ECCBanner2.jpg (12577 bytes)

 

 

 home          about          recordings          portal          contact


Edge City Record Reviews

Click a title or scroll down:

Guitarrasalto          Kosmischstrasse          Aktivavoco

 

Full article archives: 

JazzReview
Philadelphia Weekly
PauseRecord

Guitarrasalto

 

"The moment I received [Guitarrasalto] and put it on my CD player, I knew that I had found a treasure... This guitar/accordion/saxophone/bass-infested delicacy is a feast for the ear where intricate tangos mix freely with avant-garde fluidity and jazzy intaglios to create a magnificent tableaux of fresh verve and exuberant vitality.  Surprisingly classical but, at the same time, audaciously new.  This is a great recording from these five independent, improvisational artists, to be had and savoured all summer long!"

- Stavros Moschopoulos, FAO Casa Gazette, Roma

 

"The Edge City Collective delivers on [its] mission with heart and great passion.  The music ebbs and flows with a sophistication rarely heard in improvised music.  Recommended."

- Drimala.com

 

"Four stars...  This CD was full of instrumental bliss."

- Kas Walters, Nefarious Magazine

 

"This collection... is all about emotion.  At times reminiscent of Paulinho Noguira and other great Brazilian jazz artists... "Upekuzi" is as pretty as anything Henry Kaiser and Donald Lindley have discovered on their journeys through Mozambique. When their pieces become harsher and more experimental, as in the title track and "Fanatango Primo" (which includes brilliant flute work by Jon Thompson), the pleasures are less immediate, but once again strongly rewarding.  Those who love every aspect of the guitar will love this... The Collective's focus... is very broad and diverse, appealing to fans of guitar work understated as Guy Clark or as complex as Steve Reich."  [full review]

- Theodore Defosse, Splendid E-Zine

 

"The variety of sounds they get with acoustic guitars, basses, sax, flute, melodica, accordion and a touch of mandolin is astounding... creating a palette of emotional soundscapes that is at once soothing and unsettling, urban with an occasional touch of country roots.  All instrumental, heady, and full of feeling, [Guitarrasalto] is a fascinating collection."  [full review]

- da Flower Punk, PauseRecord

 

"Who says music has to be formulaic and structured?  The group of musicians that make up the Edge City Collective make it a point to take risks and explore the unknown possibilities of music...  The dixieland jive of "Osweetmoses" merges into the experimental flamenco of "Nippon Theme", which gives way to the percussive noises and electric riffs of "Guitarrasalto." The driving sounds of "Fanatango Primo" are dramatic and intense. "The Portal" has a very modern and airy feel, and the classical guitar of "Upaya" is romantic and sweet... The experimentation keeps the music alive and enjoyable from beginning to end."

- Mish Mash Indie Music Reviews

 

"Edge City Collective is a remarkable confederacy of quiet grace, swinging jazz and musical invention. They are unclassifiable-and happily so... this is just the beginning of far-reaching recognition of Philadelphia's burgeoning avant-garde scene."

- Liz Spikol, Philadelphia Weekly

 

"What is remarkable is that on most tracks you may be hearing the first and only performance of a piece -- truly the act of creation captured for the listener's enjoyment... be sure to check out Guitarrasalto and give the Collective a critical listen."  [full review]

- Guitar Nine Records Magazine

 

"The players are all fine musicians, with chops a-plenty and the wherewithal to apply them... Each title sounds very different from the one before or after it [yet] the group does seem to maintain an identity.  If your taste in listening runs toward the sweet and tonal, pick this up."  [full review]

- Jeph Jerman, The Improvisor

 

"Four stars... an experiment in theme-based free improvisation and guerilla aesthetics... "Osweetmoses" has both Madof and Schaffer earning wows all around... "Fanatango Primo," [featuring] Ranji Kumar's accordion and Jon Thompson's flute, also stands out." 

- Jeff Morris, 52nd St. Jazz

 

"[Guitarrasalto's] 15 tracks dip into multiple cultural themes and offer up twists at each turn... Opener "Citron" is a rather atmospheric guitar and bass contemplation; "Osweetmoses" a Les Paul-ian rag; "Fanatango Secondo" explodes with post-mariachi grandeur; while the title track bobs and weaves in a John Fahey-esque lurch." 

- Brian Howard, Philadelphia City Paper

 

"[Guitarrasalto is] an eclectic, creative, improvisational product... of course calling it a product is exactly what the artists are set against... nuanced, melodious... avant-garde, experimental... the melding of genres and instruments comes off well."

- Armand Canales, The Critical Review

 

Kosmischstrasse  

 

"Cutting a dream-like montage of membranous sounds... a chain-linked stream of tone poems, the program is at once absorbing and confounding and offers a consistent sense of surprise.  Pieces of genuine lyric beauty, such as the folk-tinged "Rencontre" contend with more abstract, rambunctious entries like the playfully transitory "Sonderbar" in a manner that keeps things fresh and vital."

- Cadence (July 2002)

 

"Out of Philadelphia’s musical underground comes Edge City Collective... On Edge City’s second release, the 10-piece unit shifts arrangements, pairings and instruments to create a creepy, ambient esoteric mix of styles and traditions fusing classical, European folk and jazz... The band has doubled in size since its first recording and so has its potential, merging the album’s 24 tracks into a seamless path of exploration, capturing the band in great form."

- Daniel Piotrowsky, Signal to Noise

 

"As part two in a trilogy of improvisational music, Kosmischstrasse has the musicians in Edge City Collective exploring an even more far-out world than in part one... ECC is definitely comfortable with taking chances, and the creation that emerges seems to take on a life of its own. The improvisation here is surely alive, breathing, speaking and crying out in a fashion that is sorely absent in the mainstream."

- Mish Mash Indie Music Reviews

 

"Kosmischstrasse is a challenging and diverse album that gives no quarter to casual or inattentive listeners... Those who enjoy vigorous musical experimentation and inventive style-melding are in for a treat."

- Matthew Pollesel, Splendid E-Zine

 

"[Kosmischstrasse is] raging creativity and normalcy-be-damned inventiveness... 

"Jezihohana" is like being in the darkness behind the tent of a possibly malevolent circus while lovely "Rencontre" is much warmer with rootsy jangles and violin strands.  Crowded and discordant "Katzenmusik" sounds like several random street minstrels, Italian restaurant musicians and a jazz combo or two converged into one small room to simultaneously play their own song.  Traces of assorted ethnicities surge through entrancing reel-along, "Beledara," followed by dimly-lit avant-jazz.  If you enjoy the sounds of normal instruments being transcendentally abused into surreal performances, you'll hear almost 69 minutes of animalistic squawking, plinky strings, cartoony effects, inexplicable outbursts and even some relatively traditional sounds too."

- David Opdyke, Ambientrance

 

"[Kosmischstrasse is] highly varied, with quiet introspective acoustic tracks, as well as ones that are on the border of complete freakout... "Rencontre" mixes some light tribal percussion in with beautiful violin and acoustic guitar for a soothing and captivating track... "Phasengranze" sounds like a drunken street-corner band heard layered through reeling effects... The group is at its best [on] tracks like the excellent "Beledara"... there are definitely shining moments in some of the experimental tracks as well."

- Almostcool Music Reviews

 

"Kosmischstrasse... brings the Collective from six players to 11, significantly broadening not only the possibilities but the results"...  "Solarena"... would keep Wim Wenders and David Lynch good company... "Beledara," [is] cast in mythical Eastern shadow... "Rimbombare"... gets embellished... to excellent effect."

- Liz Spikol, Philadelphia Weekly

 

"Through an amalgam of styles and recording techniques, the fearless musicians of Edge City take the intrepid listener on an awe-inspiring ride through musical consciousness. Not for the complacent."

- Tropia.com

 

Aktivavoco

 

"Edge City Collective is a coalition of like-minded creative musicians who seem determined to defy musical categorization... The diverse nature of the disc’s seventeen tracks traverses unpredictable musical spheres. While some of the pieces are intended as deliberate reflections on the absurdities of society, others evoke satire, diversity and optimism.

"The musicians involved are all strongly adept, yet the focus is not on musical virtuosity, but rather on the imaginative and spontaneous reactions to sound. The vocalizations are all unique and integrate with the core instrumentation to create fresh textures. Dodd, who has performed with Anthony Braxton, and Miller, with mesmerizing Tuvan throat-singing, bring an abundance of creativity to the proceedings.

"The sounds of Edge City Collective are fresh, bold and challenging. Aktivavoco is the perfect remedy to cure one’s displeasure for the mundane and trivial."  
[full review]

- John Barron, JazzReview

 

"Aktivavoco is an example of what can happen when a large ensemble of diversely talented musicians get together to improvise without boundaries, drawing on a huge range of Western and Eastern spiritual/musical traditions and throwing in some poetry and political satire too… There are good things here—trumpeter Bart Miltenberger and guitarist Scott Schaffer in particular are worth listening to… the Riders in the Sky-style setting of Ralph Waldo Emerson’s poem “Brahma” (I kid you not) is the most memorable [track] on the album."

- Nate Dorward, Cadence

 

“After a free-flowing introductory duet between Dodd and Miltenberger, the program takes a series of sudden twists... The spiraling slows by the album’s seventh track, “Denove,” which playfully revisits the trumpet-vocal theme, and Aktivavoco settles into a groove defined by creative interplay between the players and singers. Dodd exudes a spiritual energy that is at turns meditative and frenetic. After “Metamorfozo” builds to peak intensity, “Ridado” releases the tension in a hilarious collage built on Thompson’s tenor solo. The album ends with the beautiful “Harmonio,” and a moving coda.

Aktivavoco is Edge City Collective’s most challenging work to date. Inventive, spontaneous and rewarding, it is a fitting end to the trilogy.”

- Sam Mitchell, The Improvisor

 

top